diff --git a/code/game/objects/items/storage/wallets.dm b/code/game/objects/items/storage/wallets.dm
index 35aa743cfb2..e58cab6c656 100644
--- a/code/game/objects/items/storage/wallets.dm
+++ b/code/game/objects/items/storage/wallets.dm
@@ -57,16 +57,19 @@
 
 	front_id = null
 	var/winning_tally = 0
+	var/is_magnetic_found = FALSE
 	for(var/obj/item/card/id/id_card in contents)
 		// Certain IDs can forcibly jump to the front so they can disguise other cards in wallets. Chameleon/Agent ID cards are an example of this.
-		if(HAS_TRAIT(id_card, TRAIT_MAGNETIC_ID_CARD))
+		if(!is_magnetic_found && HAS_TRAIT(id_card, TRAIT_MAGNETIC_ID_CARD))
 			front_id = id_card
-			break
+			is_magnetic_found = TRUE
+
+		if(!is_magnetic_found)
+			var/card_tally = SSid_access.tally_access(id_card, ACCESS_FLAG_COMMAND)
+			if(card_tally > winning_tally)
+				winning_tally = card_tally
+				front_id = id_card
 
-		var/card_tally = SSid_access.tally_access(id_card, ACCESS_FLAG_COMMAND)
-		if(card_tally > winning_tally)
-			winning_tally = card_tally
-			front_id = id_card
 		LAZYINITLIST(combined_access)
 		combined_access |= id_card.access