diff --git a/code/modules/mod/mod_paint.dm b/code/modules/mod/mod_paint.dm
index ee162b2d981..351859e5f2b 100644
--- a/code/modules/mod/mod_paint.dm
+++ b/code/modules/mod/mod_paint.dm
@@ -144,8 +144,9 @@
 		balloon_alert(user, "no alternate skins!")
 		return
 	var/list/skins = list()
-	for(var/mod_skin in mod.theme.skins)
-		skins[mod_skin] = image(icon = mod.icon, icon_state = "[mod_skin]-control")
+	for(var/mod_skin_name in mod.theme.skins)
+		var/list/mod_skin = mod.theme.skins[mod_skin_name]
+		skins[mod_skin_name] = image(icon = mod_skin[MOD_ICON_OVERRIDE] || mod.icon, icon_state = "[mod_skin_name]-control")
 	var/pick = show_radial_menu(user, mod, skins, custom_check = CALLBACK(src, PROC_REF(check_menu), mod, user), require_near = TRUE)
 	if(!pick)
 		balloon_alert(user, "no skin picked!")