diff --git a/code/modules/antagonists/cult/cult_items.dm b/code/modules/antagonists/cult/cult_items.dm
index ca9a34a2862..60156c50ff6 100644
--- a/code/modules/antagonists/cult/cult_items.dm
+++ b/code/modules/antagonists/cult/cult_items.dm
@@ -459,6 +459,9 @@ Striking a noncultist, however, will tear their flesh."}
 	desc = "Toxic to nonbelievers; reinvigorating to the faithful - this flask may be sipped or thrown."
 	icon = 'icons/obj/drinks/bottles.dmi'
 	icon_state = "holyflask"
+	inhand_icon_state = "holyflask"
+	lefthand_file = 'icons/mob/inhands/items/drinks_lefthand.dmi'
+	righthand_file = 'icons/mob/inhands/items/drinks_righthand.dmi'
 	color = "#333333"
 	list_reagents = list(/datum/reagent/fuel/unholywater = 50)
 
diff --git a/code/modules/reagents/reagent_containers/cups/glassbottle.dm b/code/modules/reagents/reagent_containers/cups/glassbottle.dm
index 0ff6df28941..f5271d0ab45 100644
--- a/code/modules/reagents/reagent_containers/cups/glassbottle.dm
+++ b/code/modules/reagents/reagent_containers/cups/glassbottle.dm
@@ -18,6 +18,7 @@
 	throwforce = 15
 	demolition_mod = 0.25
 	inhand_icon_state = "beer" //Generic held-item sprite until unique ones are made.
+	var/broken_inhand_icon_state = "broken_beer"
 	lefthand_file = 'icons/mob/inhands/items/drinks_lefthand.dmi'
 	righthand_file = 'icons/mob/inhands/items/drinks_righthand.dmi'
 	drink_type = ALCOHOL
@@ -40,6 +41,7 @@
 	if(!ranged && thrower)
 		thrower.put_in_hands(B)
 	B.mimic_broken(src, target, break_top)
+	B.inhand_icon_state = broken_inhand_icon_state
 
 	qdel(src)
 	target.Bumped(B)
@@ -305,6 +307,7 @@
 	icon = 'icons/obj/drinks/bottles.dmi'
 	icon_state = "holyflask"
 	inhand_icon_state = "holyflask"
+	broken_inhand_icon_state = "broken_holyflask"
 	list_reagents = list(/datum/reagent/water/holywater = 100)
 	drink_type = NONE
 
diff --git a/icons/mob/inhands/items/drinks_lefthand.dmi b/icons/mob/inhands/items/drinks_lefthand.dmi
index edbffeee2fc..6d7cc042f77 100644
Binary files a/icons/mob/inhands/items/drinks_lefthand.dmi and b/icons/mob/inhands/items/drinks_lefthand.dmi differ
diff --git a/icons/mob/inhands/items/drinks_righthand.dmi b/icons/mob/inhands/items/drinks_righthand.dmi
index 9a2d2d1e6b6..02756cb6448 100644
Binary files a/icons/mob/inhands/items/drinks_righthand.dmi and b/icons/mob/inhands/items/drinks_righthand.dmi differ