diff --git a/code/modules/admin/topic.dm b/code/modules/admin/topic.dm
index e29e08b937e..1c3776eb9ae 100644
--- a/code/modules/admin/topic.dm
+++ b/code/modules/admin/topic.dm
@@ -939,18 +939,7 @@
 		if(!ishuman(H))
 			to_chat(usr, "This can only be used on instances of type /mob/living/carbon/human.", confidential = TRUE)
 			return
-		//let's keep it simple
-		//milk to plasmemes and skeletons, meat to lizards, electricity bars to ethereals, cookies to everyone else
-		var/cookiealt = /obj/item/food/cookie
-		if(isskeleton(H))
-			cookiealt = /obj/item/reagent_containers/food/condiment/milk
-		else if(isplasmaman(H))
-			cookiealt = /obj/item/reagent_containers/food/condiment/milk
-		else if(isethereal(H))
-			cookiealt = /obj/item/food/energybar
-		else if(islizard(H))
-			cookiealt = /obj/item/food/meat/slab
-		var/obj/item/new_item = new cookiealt(H)
+		var/obj/item/new_item = new H.dna.species.species_cookie(H)
 		if(H.put_in_hands(new_item))
 			H.update_inv_hands()
 		else
diff --git a/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species.dm b/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species.dm
index c3f9e1de95c..4507ad5c5d3 100644
--- a/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species.dm
+++ b/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species.dm
@@ -211,6 +211,9 @@ GLOBAL_LIST_EMPTY(features_by_species)
 	///Bitflag that controls what in game ways something can select this species as a spawnable source, such as magic mirrors. See [mob defines][code/__DEFINES/mobs.dm] for possible sources.
 	var/changesource_flags = NONE
 
+	///Unique cookie given by admins through prayers
+	var/species_cookie = /obj/item/food/cookie
+
 	///For custom overrides for species ass images
 	var/icon/ass_image
 
diff --git a/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/ethereal.dm b/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/ethereal.dm
index e4a97328772..0e4176a5266 100644
--- a/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/ethereal.dm
+++ b/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/ethereal.dm
@@ -17,6 +17,7 @@
 	damage_overlay_type = "" //We are too cool for regular damage overlays
 	species_traits = list(DYNCOLORS, AGENDER, NO_UNDERWEAR, HAIR, FACEHAIR, HAS_FLESH, HAS_BONE) // i mean i guess they have blood so they can have wounds too
 	changesource_flags = MIRROR_BADMIN | WABBAJACK | MIRROR_PRIDE | MIRROR_MAGIC | RACE_SWAP | ERT_SPAWN | SLIME_EXTRACT
+	species_cookie = /obj/item/food/energybar
 	species_language_holder = /datum/language_holder/ethereal
 	sexes = FALSE //no fetish content allowed
 	toxic_food = NONE
diff --git a/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/lizardpeople.dm b/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/lizardpeople.dm
index 2e695aa2e84..9347f55f7d8 100644
--- a/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/lizardpeople.dm
+++ b/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/lizardpeople.dm
@@ -22,6 +22,7 @@
 	heatmod = 0.67
 	payday_modifier = 0.75
 	changesource_flags = MIRROR_BADMIN | WABBAJACK | MIRROR_PRIDE | MIRROR_MAGIC | RACE_SWAP | ERT_SPAWN | SLIME_EXTRACT
+	species_cookie = /obj/item/food/meat/slab
 	attack_verb = "slash"
 	attack_effect = ATTACK_EFFECT_CLAW
 	attack_sound = 'sound/weapons/slash.ogg'
diff --git a/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/plasmamen.dm b/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/plasmamen.dm
index 5d34c91b2b3..3f6cbc1fa79 100644
--- a/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/plasmamen.dm
+++ b/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/plasmamen.dm
@@ -31,6 +31,7 @@
 	disliked_food = FRUIT | CLOTH
 	liked_food = VEGETABLES
 	changesource_flags = MIRROR_BADMIN | WABBAJACK | MIRROR_PRIDE | MIRROR_MAGIC
+	species_cookie = /obj/item/reagent_containers/food/condiment/milk
 	outfit_important_for_life = /datum/outfit/plasmaman
 	species_language_holder = /datum/language_holder/skeleton
 
diff --git a/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/skeletons.dm b/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/skeletons.dm
index 302f06f052b..67b0712254e 100644
--- a/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/skeletons.dm
+++ b/code/modules/mob/living/carbon/human/species_types/skeletons.dm
@@ -36,6 +36,7 @@
 	wings_icons = list("Skeleton")
 	//They can technically be in an ERT
 	changesource_flags = MIRROR_BADMIN | WABBAJACK | ERT_SPAWN
+	species_cookie = /obj/item/reagent_containers/food/condiment/milk
 	species_language_holder = /datum/language_holder/skeleton
 
 	bodypart_overrides = list(