diff --git a/code/modules/awaymissions/mission_code/wildwest.dm b/code/modules/awaymissions/mission_code/wildwest.dm
index 964d546be67..03d1476ee30 100644
--- a/code/modules/awaymissions/mission_code/wildwest.dm
+++ b/code/modules/awaymissions/mission_code/wildwest.dm
@@ -88,7 +88,7 @@
 	else
 		chargesa--
 		insistinga = 0
-		var/wish = input("You want...","Wish") as null|anything in list("Power","Wealth","Immortality","To Kill","Peace")
+		var/wish = input("You want...","Wish") as null|anything in list("Power","Wealth","Immortality","Peace")
 		switch(wish)
 			if("Power")
 				to_chat(user, "<B>Your wish is granted, but at a terrible cost...</B>")
@@ -107,11 +107,6 @@
 				to_chat(user, "The Wish Granter punishes you for your selfishness, claiming your soul and warping your body to match the darkness in your heart.")
 				user.verbs += /mob/living/carbon/proc/immortality
 				user.set_species(/datum/species/shadow)
-			if("To Kill")
-				to_chat(user, "<B>Your wish is granted, but at a terrible cost...</B>")
-				to_chat(user, "The Wish Granter punishes you for your wickedness, claiming your soul and warping your body to match the darkness in your heart.")
-				user.mind.add_antag_datum(/datum/antagonist/wishgranter)
-				user.set_species(/datum/species/shadow)
 			if("Peace")
 				to_chat(user, "<B>Whatever alien sentience that the Wish Granter possesses is satisfied with your wish. There is a distant wailing as the last of the Faithless begin to die, then silence.</B>")
 				to_chat(user, "You feel as if you just narrowly avoided a terrible fate...")