diff --git a/icons/map_icons/items/_item.dmi b/icons/map_icons/items/_item.dmi
index d0d8f4b10c2..89318fe4157 100644
Binary files a/icons/map_icons/items/_item.dmi and b/icons/map_icons/items/_item.dmi differ
diff --git a/modular_skyrat/master_files/icons/mob/sprite_accessory/fish_tails.dmi b/modular_skyrat/master_files/icons/mob/sprite_accessory/fish_tails.dmi
deleted file mode 100644
index fa91a6d97fd..00000000000
Binary files a/modular_skyrat/master_files/icons/mob/sprite_accessory/fish_tails.dmi and /dev/null differ
diff --git a/modular_skyrat/modules/customization/modules/mob/dead/new_player/sprite_accessories/tails.dm b/modular_skyrat/modules/customization/modules/mob/dead/new_player/sprite_accessories/tails.dm
index a742ca1d468..1c2f28bbb86 100644
--- a/modular_skyrat/modules/customization/modules/mob/dead/new_player/sprite_accessories/tails.dm
+++ b/modular_skyrat/modules/customization/modules/mob/dead/new_player/sprite_accessories/tails.dm
@@ -39,7 +39,7 @@
 	color_src = USE_ONE_COLOR
 
 /datum/sprite_accessory/tails/fish
-	icon = 'modular_skyrat/master_files/icons/mob/sprite_accessory/fish_tails.dmi'
+	organ_type = /obj/item/organ/tail/fake_fish //copypasta of dna infusion fish tails but without the quirks (beside butchering)
 
 /datum/sprite_accessory/tails/xeno/default
 	icon = 'modular_skyrat/master_files/icons/mob/sprite_accessory/xeno_tail.dmi'
diff --git a/modular_skyrat/modules/customization/modules/surgery/organs/tails.dm b/modular_skyrat/modules/customization/modules/surgery/organs/tails.dm
index cabec5734d7..d7688a76f85 100644
--- a/modular_skyrat/modules/customization/modules/surgery/organs/tails.dm
+++ b/modular_skyrat/modules/customization/modules/surgery/organs/tails.dm
@@ -64,3 +64,46 @@
 	name = "fluffy tail"
 
 /obj/item/organ/tail/fluffy/no_wag
+
+///A tail that replicates the appearance of fish tails from DNA infusion, but without most of the code that makes them so special.
+/obj/item/organ/tail/fake_fish
+	name = /obj/item/organ/tail/fish::name
+	desc = /obj/item/organ/tail/fish::desc
+	icon = /obj/item/organ/tail/fish::icon
+	icon_state = /obj/item/organ/tail/fish::icon_state
+	post_init_icon_state = /obj/item/organ/tail/fish::post_init_icon_state
+	greyscale_config = /obj/item/organ/tail/fish::greyscale_config
+	greyscale_colors = /obj/item/organ/tail/fish::greyscale_colors
+
+	bodypart_overlay = /obj/item/organ/tail/fish::bodypart_overlay
+	wag_flags = /obj/item/organ/tail/fish::wag_flags
+	restyle_flags = /obj/item/organ/tail/fish::restyle_flags
+
+	// Fishlike reagents, you could serve it raw like fish
+	food_reagents = /obj/item/organ/tail/fish::food_reagents
+	// Seafood instead of meat, because it's a fish organ
+	foodtype_flags = /obj/item/organ/tail/fish::foodtype_flags
+	// Also just tastes like fish
+	food_tastes = /obj/item/organ/tail/fish::food_tastes
+	/// The fillet type this fish tail is processable into
+	var/fillet_type = /obj/item/food/fishmeat/fish_tail
+	/// The amount of fillets this gets processed into
+	var/fillet_amount = 3
+
+/obj/item/organ/tail/fake_fish/Initialize(mapload)
+	. = ..()
+	var/time_to_fillet = fillet_amount * 0.5 SECONDS
+	AddElement(/datum/element/processable, TOOL_KNIFE, fillet_type, fillet_amount, time_to_fillet, screentip_verb = "Cut")
+
+/obj/item/organ/tail/fake_fish/on_mob_insert(mob/living/carbon/owner)
+	. = ..()
+	RegisterSignal(owner, COMSIG_LIVING_GIBBER_ACT, PROC_REF(on_gibber_processed))
+
+/obj/item/organ/tail/fake_fish/on_mob_remove(mob/living/carbon/owner)
+	. = ..()
+	UnregisterSignal(owner, COMSIG_LIVING_GIBBER_ACT)
+
+/obj/item/organ/tail/fake_fish/proc/on_gibber_processed(mob/living/carbon/owner, mob/living/user, obj/machinery/gibber, list/results)
+	SIGNAL_HANDLER
+	for(var/iteration in 1 to fillet_amount * 0.5)
+		results += new fillet_type