Animals ripping out organs will get organ items instead of meat slabs.

code/modules/food/food/snacks.dm

@@ -802,10 +802,18 @@
 	center_of_mass = list("x"=16, "y"=16)
 	bitesize = 3
 
-/obj/item/reagent_containers/food/snacks/organ/Initialize()
+/obj/item/reagent_containers/food/snacks/organ/Initialize(var/ml, var/obj/item/organ/donor)
 	. = ..()
 	reagents.add_reagent("protein", rand(3,5))
 	reagents.add_reagent("toxin", rand(1,3))
+	if(donor)
+		appearance = donor
+		if(donor.reagents?.total_volume)
+			donor.reagents.trans_to(src, donor.reagents.total_volume)
+		fingerprints =       donor.fingerprints?.Copy()
+		fingerprintshidden = donor.fingerprintshidden?.Copy()
+		fingerprintslast =   donor.fingerprintslast
+		qdel(donor)
 
 /obj/item/reagent_containers/food/snacks/tofu
 	name = "Tofu"

code/modules/mob/living/simple_mob/subtypes/animal/animal.dm

@@ -104,10 +104,9 @@
 
 	if(istype(snack, /obj/item/organ))
 		var/obj/item/organ/organ = snack
-		if(organ.meat_type)
-			snack = new organ.meat_type(src)
-			qdel(organ)
-	else if(!istype(snack) || !snack.reagents?.total_volume)
+		if(organ.meat_type) // Let's assume not having a meat_type means it's not edible.
+			snack = new /obj/item/reagent_containers/food/snacks/organ(get_turf(snack), snack)
+	if(!istype(snack) || !snack.reagents?.total_volume)
 		to_chat(src, SPAN_WARNING("\The [snack] doesn't seem edible."))
 		return
 

code/modules/organs/organ.dm

@@ -431,20 +431,7 @@ var/global/list/organ_cache = list()
 	blood_splatter(src,B,1)
 
 	user.drop_from_inventory(src)
-	var/obj/item/reagent_containers/food/snacks/organ/O = new(get_turf(src))
-	O.name = name
-	O.icon = icon
-	O.icon_state = icon_state
-
-	// Pass over the blood.
-	reagents.trans_to(O, reagents.total_volume)
-
-	if(fingerprints) O.fingerprints = fingerprints.Copy()
-	if(fingerprintshidden) O.fingerprintshidden = fingerprintshidden.Copy()
-	if(fingerprintslast) O.fingerprintslast = fingerprintslast
-
-	user.put_in_active_hand(O)
-	qdel(src)
+	user.put_in_active_hand(new /obj/item/reagent_containers/food/snacks/organ(get_turf(src), src))
 
 /obj/item/organ/attack_self(mob/user as mob)