holy shit it actually works

code/modules/reagents/chemistry/reagents/medicine_reagents.dm

@@ -483,32 +483,23 @@
 	reagent_state = LIQUID
 	color = "#E6FFF0"
 	metabolization_rate = 0.5 * REAGENTS_METABOLISM
+	var/healtoxinlover = FALSE
 
 /datum/reagent/medicine/pen_acid/on_mob_life(mob/living/carbon/M)
 	M.radiation -= max(M.radiation-RAD_MOB_SAFE, 0)/50
-	M.adjustToxLoss(-2*REM, 0)
+	M.adjustToxLoss(-2*REM, 0, healtoxinlover)
 	for(var/datum/reagent/R in M.reagents.reagent_list)
 		if(R != src)
 			M.reagents.remove_reagent(R.id,2)
 	..()
 	. = 1
 
-/datum/reagent/medicine/pen_jelly
+/datum/reagent/medicine/pen_acid/pen_jelly
 	name = "Pentetic Jelly"
 	id = "pen_jelly"
 	description = "Reduces massive amounts of radiation and toxin damage while purging other chemicals from the body. Slimepeople friendly!"
-	reagent_state = LIQUID
-	color = "#E6FFF0"
-	metabolization_rate = 0.5 * REAGENTS_METABOLISM
-
-/datum/reagent/medicine/pen_jelly/on_mob_life(mob/living/carbon/M)
-	M.radiation -= max(M.radiation-RAD_MOB_SAFE, 0)/50
-	M.adjustToxLoss(-2*REM, 0, TRUE) //HEALS TOXINOVERS
-	for(var/datum/reagent/R in M.reagents.reagent_list)
-		if(R != src)
-			M.reagents.remove_reagent(R.id,2)
-	..()
-	. = 1
+	color = "#91D865"
+	healtoxinlover = TRUE
 
 /datum/reagent/medicine/sal_acid
 	name = "Salicyclic Acid"

code/modules/reagents/chemistry/recipes/medicine.dm

@@ -97,7 +97,7 @@
 /datum/chemical_reaction/pen_jelly
 	name = "Pentetic Jelly"
 	id = "pen_jelly"
-	results = list("pen_acid" = 2)
+	results = list("pen_jelly" = 2)
 	required_reagents = list("pen_acid" = 1, "slimejelly" = 1)
 
 /datum/chemical_reaction/sal_acid