diff --git a/code/game/machinery/computer/arcade.dm b/code/game/machinery/computer/arcade.dm
index 4bce450359..b988bd8d35 100644
--- a/code/game/machinery/computer/arcade.dm
+++ b/code/game/machinery/computer/arcade.dm
@@ -1,8 +1,7 @@
 #define ARCADE_WEIGHT_TRICK 4
 #define ARCADE_WEIGHT_USELESS 2
 #define ARCADE_WEIGHT_RARE 1
-#define ARCADE_WEIGHT_PLUSH 65
-
+#define ARCADE_RATIO_PLUSH 0.20 // average 1 out of 6 wins is a plush.
 
 /obj/machinery/computer/arcade
 	name = "random arcade"
@@ -27,7 +26,6 @@
 		/obj/item/toy/katana = ARCADE_WEIGHT_TRICK,
 		/obj/item/toy/minimeteor = ARCADE_WEIGHT_TRICK,
 		/obj/item/toy/nuke = ARCADE_WEIGHT_TRICK,
-		/obj/item/toy/plush/random = ARCADE_WEIGHT_PLUSH,
 		/obj/item/toy/redbutton = ARCADE_WEIGHT_TRICK,
 		/obj/item/toy/spinningtoy = ARCADE_WEIGHT_TRICK,
 		/obj/item/toy/sword = ARCADE_WEIGHT_TRICK,
@@ -90,6 +88,9 @@
 		var/obj/item/circuitboard/CB = new thegame()
 		new CB.build_path(loc, CB)
 		return INITIALIZE_HINT_QDEL
+	//The below object acts as a spawner with a wide array of possible picks, most being uninspired references to past/current player characters.
+	//Nevertheless, this keeps its ratio constant with the sum of all the others prizes.
+	prizes[/obj/item/toy/plush/random] = counterlist_sum(prizes) * ARCADE_RATIO_PLUSH
 	Reset()
 
 /obj/machinery/computer/arcade/proc/prizevend(mob/user, list/rarity_classes)
diff --git a/code/game/objects/items/plushes.dm b/code/game/objects/items/plushes.dm
index 48588cf9f3..4847919a08 100644
--- a/code/game/objects/items/plushes.dm
+++ b/code/game/objects/items/plushes.dm
@@ -366,10 +366,10 @@
 /obj/item/toy/plush/random
 	name = "Illegal plushie"
 	desc = "Something fucked up"
+	var/blacklisted_plushes = list(/obj/item/toy/plush/carpplushie/dehy_carp, /obj/item/toy/plush/awakenedplushie, /obj/item/toy/plush/random)
 
 /obj/item/toy/plush/random/Initialize()
-	..()
-	var/newtype = pick(subtypesof(/obj/item/toy/plush))
+	var/newtype = pick(subtypesof(/obj/item/toy/plush) - typecacheof(blacklisted_plushes))
 	new newtype(loc)
 	return INITIALIZE_HINT_QDEL