diff --git a/code/game/gamemodes/objective.dm b/code/game/gamemodes/objective.dm
index 4c82046e07..bb18b89678 100644
--- a/code/game/gamemodes/objective.dm
+++ b/code/game/gamemodes/objective.dm
@@ -787,40 +787,10 @@ GLOBAL_LIST_EMPTY(possible_items_special)
 /datum/objective/destroy/internal
 	var/stolen = FALSE 		//Have we already eliminated this target?
 
-/datum/objective/steal_five_of_type
-	name = "steal five of"
-	explanation_text = "Steal at least five items!"
-	var/list/wanted_items = list(/obj/item)
-
-/datum/objective/steal_five_of_type/New()
-	..()
-	wanted_items = typecacheof(wanted_items)
-
-/datum/objective/steal_five_of_type/summon_guns
-	name = "steal guns"
-	explanation_text = "Steal at least five guns!"
-	wanted_items = list(/obj/item/gun)
-
-/datum/objective/steal_five_of_type/summon_magic
-	name = "steal magic"
-	explanation_text = "Steal at least five magical artefacts!"
-	wanted_items = list(/obj/item/spellbook, /obj/item/gun/magic, /obj/item/clothing/suit/space/hardsuit/wizard, /obj/item/scrying, /obj/item/antag_spawner/contract, /obj/item/necromantic_stone)
-
-/datum/objective/steal_five_of_type/check_completion()
-	var/list/datum/mind/owners = get_owners()
-	var/stolen_count = 0
-	for(var/datum/mind/M in owners)
-		if(!isliving(M.current))
-			continue
-		var/list/all_items = M.current.GetAllContents()	//this should get things in cheesewheels, books, etc.
-		for(var/obj/I in all_items) //Check for wanted items
-			if(is_type_in_typecache(I, wanted_items))
-				stolen_count++
-	return stolen_count >= 5
-
 //Created by admin tools
 /datum/objective/custom
 	name = "custom"
+	completable = FALSE
 
 /datum/objective/custom/admin_edit(mob/admin)
 	var/expl = stripped_input(admin, "Custom objective:", "Objective", explanation_text)
@@ -998,4 +968,33 @@ GLOBAL_LIST_EMPTY(possible_items_special)
 	command_staff_only = TRUE
 
 
+/datum/objective/horde
+	name = "horde"
+	var/obj/item/horded_item = null
 
+/datum/objective/horde/get_target()
+	return horded_item
+
+/datum/objective/horde/proc/set_target(obj/item/I)
+	if(item)
+		horded_item = I
+		explanation_text = "Keep [I] on your person at all costs."
+		return horded_item
+	else
+		explanation_text = "Free objective"
+		return
+
+/datum/objective/horde/check_completion()
+	var/list/datum/mind/owners = get_owners()
+	if(!horded_item)
+		return TRUE
+	for(var/datum/mind/M in owners)
+		if(!isliving(M.current))
+			continue
+
+		var/list/all_items = M.current.GetAllContents()	//this should get things in cheesewheels, books, etc.
+
+		for(var/obj/I in all_items) //Check for items
+			if(I == horded_item)
+				return TRUE
+	return FALSE
diff --git a/code/modules/antagonists/survivalist/survivalist.dm b/code/modules/antagonists/survivalist/survivalist.dm
index 4e0184b7b6..5334bb0f41 100644
--- a/code/modules/antagonists/survivalist/survivalist.dm
+++ b/code/modules/antagonists/survivalist/survivalist.dm
@@ -2,6 +2,7 @@
 	name = "Survivalist"
 	show_in_antagpanel = FALSE
 	show_name_in_check_antagonists = TRUE
+	blacklisted_quirks = list("Pacifist") // mutes are allowed
 	var/greet_message = ""
 
 /datum/antagonist/survivalist/proc/forge_objectives()
@@ -19,7 +20,7 @@
 	owner.announce_objectives()
 
 /datum/antagonist/survivalist/guns
-	greet_message = "Your own safety matters above all else, and the only way to ensure your safety is to stockpile weapons! Grab as many guns as possible, by any means necessary. Kill anyone who gets in your way."
+	greet_message = "Your own safety matters above all else, and the only way to ensure your safety is to stockpile weapons! Grab as many guns as possible, and don't let anyone take them!"
 
 /datum/antagonist/survivalist/guns/forge_objectives()
 	var/datum/objective/steal_five_of_type/summon_guns/guns = new
@@ -29,10 +30,10 @@
 
 /datum/antagonist/survivalist/magic
 	name = "Amateur Magician"
-	greet_message = "Grow your newfound talent! Grab as many magical artefacts as possible, by any means necessary. Kill anyone who gets in your way."
+	greet_message = "This magic stuff is... so powerful. You want more. More! They want your power. They can't have it! Don't let them have it!"
 
 /datum/antagonist/survivalist/magic/forge_objectives()
 	var/datum/objective/steal_five_of_type/summon_magic/magic = new
 	magic.owner = owner
 	objectives += magic
-	..()
\ No newline at end of file
+	..()
diff --git a/code/modules/spells/spell_types/rightandwrong.dm b/code/modules/spells/spell_types/rightandwrong.dm
index e5e856c630..b73929fc44 100644
--- a/code/modules/spells/spell_types/rightandwrong.dm
+++ b/code/modules/spells/spell_types/rightandwrong.dm
@@ -102,6 +102,12 @@ GLOBAL_VAR_INIT(summon_magic_triggered, FALSE)
 	var/gun_type = pick(GLOB.summoned_guns)
 	var/obj/item/gun/G = new gun_type(get_turf(H))
 	G.unlock()
+	var/datum/antagonist/survalist/guns/our_antag_datum = has_antag_datum(/datum/antagonist/survivalist/guns)
+	if(our_antag_datum)
+		var/datum/objective/horde_item/O = new()
+		O.owner = H
+		O.set_target(G)
+		our_antag_datum.objectives += O
 	playsound(get_turf(H),'sound/magic/summon_guns.ogg', 50, 1)
 
 	var/in_hand = H.put_in_hands(G) // not always successful
@@ -128,6 +134,13 @@ GLOBAL_VAR_INIT(summon_magic_triggered, FALSE)
 	var/obj/item/M = new magic_type(get_turf(H))
 	playsound(get_turf(H),'sound/magic/summon_magic.ogg', 50, 1)
 
+	var/datum/antagonist/survalist/magic/our_antag_datum = has_antag_datum(/datum/antagonist/survivalist/magic)
+	if(our_antag_datum)
+		var/datum/objective/horde_item/O = new()
+		O.owner = H
+		O.set_target(M)
+		our_antag_datum.objectives += O
+
 	var/in_hand = H.put_in_hands(M)
 
 	to_chat(H, "<span class='warning'>\A [M] appears [in_hand ? "in your hand" : "at your feet"]!</span>")