diff --git a/code/modules/reagents/chemistry/recipes/toxins.dm b/code/modules/reagents/chemistry/recipes/toxins.dm
index 8f18c4d5ae..726175a6c6 100644
--- a/code/modules/reagents/chemistry/recipes/toxins.dm
+++ b/code/modules/reagents/chemistry/recipes/toxins.dm
@@ -124,5 +124,5 @@
 	name = "Bone Hurting Juice"
 	id = "bonehurtingjuice"
 	results = list("bonehurtingjuice" = 5)
-	required_reagents = list(/datum/reagent/toxin/mutagen = 1, /datum/reagent/toxin/itching_powder = 3, /datum/reagent/consumable/milk = 1)
+	required_reagents = list("mutagen" = 1, "itching_powder" = 3, "milk" = 1)
 	mix_message = "<span class='danger'>The mixture suddenly becomes clear and looks a lot like water. You feel a strong urge to drink it.</span>"